Sons do not want to pay 200 yuan 20 yuan per month

only to parents of 20 dollars a month alimony, and some people thought it was a joke. Seventies the three forces and Li Yang Yang, the son of perianth white to court, the son of Yang White asked the court to his parents every month to 200 yuan to 20 yuan lower maintenance costs. The case was recently dismissed the Nanning Intermediate People's Court.
as alimony














son of two parents in court

parents old son to the parents right and proper maintenance, but the three forces and Yang Yang Li, the son of white flowers because of the alimony has been reluctant to give the court the two.
Yang, Sanli, Lee has two sons, four daughters spent. September 2000, Yang Sanli, Lee took the children and uncles, called to discuss pension issues, the formation of a consensus through consultation. Two elderly people living by the two sons of Yang white Yang Xi paid 200 yuan per person per month. A three-story buildings used by the average of two sons, outstanding housing debt in equal shares. Responsibility of the home field is also used by the average operating two sons, and the remaining four daughters the right to use its share of housing to the use of two sons, arrived for maintenance.
agreement forms, Yang Bai, Yang HI according to the contract paid to the two elderly people living expenses. September 2001, Young stopped paying the two old white living expenses. In 2002, three of Yang, Li Yang, white flowers and the first time because of maintenance problems in court, the second instance is final, effective decision shall determine the Young white 6 year 2002, the two old men from the burden of living expenses per month 200.
Yang and Lee spent three forces thought the matter, they will be stable later in life to live. Unexpectedly, in 2008, the son of Yang, the two old men in turn sued the white South District Court,nike mercurial, requested that the monthly maintenance fee of 200 yuan to 20 yuan lower.
find many excuses

do not want to pay 200 maintenance

Yang White said he was injured in the waist, not engaged in manual work, no housing to live, life difficulties, Parents of 200 yuan a month he could not afford to give alimony, 20 yuan per month is appropriate.
Yang White also mentioned in the indictment, paving the monthly rental income of the parents quite good, in turn responsibility farmland rented to others, rent a substantial income each year, parents have adequate protection of life, the parents ask He gave 200 per month maintenance fee, it will affect his life, to make his life more difficult. Son of prosecution, so the two old very sad and helpless.
Yang, Sanli, Lee said the flower, the son of Yang white lie, what does not exist as back his son to say, the son and daughter of the monthly income of not less than 4000-5000 yuan. They also did not put the responsibility on field rental to others, are their own planting, and no one rental housing for many years. Building a house Shihai borrowed some money, plus repayment of debt owed by housing costs, are two old life is extremely difficult.
two elderly people also suggested that the maintenance is the son of a six or seven years ago, court decisions, so many years, prices have been soaring, they also increase the cost of living did not ask his son,mercurial vapor superfly, and son, but to no income is and life difficult on the grounds require 200 yuan / month reduced to 20 yuan / month, does make them very sad.
court decision

not justified the court does not support

Gangnam District Court hearing that three of Yang Yang Bai as Li took the son bear the maintenance of two The old man's obligation. September 2000 the formation of their maintenance agreement negotiation, Department of Yang white with parents and others the true meaning that the evidence provided by White Young proved that he can not afford to give parents 200 yuan per month alimony, but also can not prove that their parents have adequate protection of life . Moreover, the standard of living today than in the past has increased, their parents and future health care needs, 200 state maintenance, there is nothing wrong. Therefore, Yang Bai required to pay alimony from their parents by 200 yuan per month was 20 yuan, not justified, the court shall not be supported. (Text characters are not his real name)