Learning along students of parents sued the comput

present, one ascent trall over students puppy love, has been gradually guide to social concerns. However, the responsibility of puppy love for high school students, folk tend to just stay in the moral and social level,christian louboutin heels, from school, family, rational inquiry of three aspects of society, have not found a real solution to the problem. Wuxi City, Jiangsu Province, with puppy love caused by parents of students requiring schools to bear the legal responsibility of the case, has aroused excellent care and extensive hot: puppy love of learning of students, parents sued the school is not required to Schools bear the legal responsibility? Can schools liable for students in puppy love?
students puppy love, the school should bear legal responsibility for this?
Jiangzhong Fan / text

parents hundreds of miles away son to the notable private school, and signed with the school full graduate school fees. The thought then can no longer worry about his son's school. Who knows, my son entering junior middle schools, it actually took place with the school for a girls puppy love, to make learning seriously affected. To school, parents had to re-transfer to the origin of his son to study. To this end, the two sides should converge on whether school fees refunded,asics for women, and whether the schools should be liable for disagreement, and lawsuit went to court.
hopeful son of puppy love, school choice at their own outlay results fell

Liang Liqing, immediately 18-year-old man in Xuzhou City, Jiangsu Province, his childhood as natty, study hard, acquired good grades, so that parents are very proud. After primary school, Liang Liqing parents perusing to his son's school is not very satisfied with the quality of education, in order to let his son have a better learning environment for his son's school have a greater level of correction, Liang Liqing's parents have been surprising the son to better schools to study.
2000 年 7 months, only 9 years antique Liang Liqing will be promoted to fourth grade learning. After production inquiries of their parents, combined with introduction of a friend and go to the school study,80后夫妻结婚三年冷战两年终离婚 两年见面两次, as compared, that a private school in Wuxi (referred to private schools) in terms of school size, school environment, teaching quality, management, or educating are very good, but attract Liang Liqing parents is that the private schools is implemented in kindergarten, elementary, middle to high school ten to Five Years education. Compared to other schools, the school's fees are not cheap, high partition 1 million per student per year, middle school section of 6,500 yuan per student per year, per student per year primary segment has approached 4,500 yuan. Since his son was youth, Wuxi, Xuzhou have more than five hundred kilometers away from, Liang Liqing parents heart to forget, but to his son's hereafter, they ultimately judged to transfer to the school his son to learn.
2000 年 7 8, Liang Liqing's father, Liang Yiming deposit to pay 500 yuan to private schools. In the same year above July 19, Liang Yiming paid to private schools in fourth grade and third grade school to lofty school costs 53,500 yuan. August 30, 2000, Liang Yiming as parents (B) and private (party) signed the gathering to pay costs of school construction principles are as usual: two dropped out during the year, every year, subtract 1 million (less than 1 year as 1 year); more than two years, no refund. learning and life, resulting in lack of healthy physical and mental evolution of students, Party B should be allowed to retreat and transfer students, and returned to Party B to pay the headmaster portion of school construction costs, provided by Wuxi Municipal Price Bureau, the yearly fee Party net. During the private schools, Liang Liqing academic performance has been steadily, pile up amenable location, Liang Liqing's parents are very pleased almost this. September 2003, Liang Liqing with medals junior high school rose to the Ministry of successful learning.
2004 in the second half, 13-year-old Liang Liqing into the growth and development of the body, opening to show secondary ######ual specifics, psychological alterations emulated, he produced the same school girls, a different kind of Chen Xue business. Chen Xue during puberty with out end up svelte, pretty, pleasant, young girls started to Chen Xue-specific heart stirring feelings. Two Qingdouchukai boys and girls, learning the common love for every other had, and the establishment of a relationship. As the two young puppy love does not correctly handle the relationship with the learning they simply inundated in the joy of love in the academic performance has been greatly affected.
two days of school, is the most momentous year in the junior secondary class. But, but why at this stage, the son of the grades fell, granting Liang Liqing parents are quite impatient. First half of 2005, the son of the second semester of the 1st two days learning stage, in order to ascertain his son scores ebb, and Liang Liqing parents additional the number of times to visit his son, and careful detection, eventually base his son and Chen Xue passed a lot of memorandum more content narrated to legend. This allows Liang Liqing parents suddenly realized that his son had puppy love with the woman students.
son of puppy love, extraordinary child's melodrama. Liang Liqing parents to communicate with the school immediately, hoping to prevent his son's puppy love with Chen Xue. Schools were also seeing for Liang Liqing and Chen Xue speak, and to strengthen education. However, Liang Liqing and Chen Xue learn individually vouched, is not love, but below they still go its own course, more so. In this regard, schools and parents are helpless. In desperation, the parents realized that only his son Liang Liqing Chen Xue away to tear off two of puppy love. So, August 29, 2005, Liang Liqing parents to the nearest school grounds, apply to transfer to private schools, private schools to agree Liang Liqing parents reading his son back to origin.
frustration at loggerheads over the transfer of a dispute v. Shanggong Tang

mandate to smoothly migrate, handling the transmit formalities for his son, Liang Liqing's parents will not refer to anybody economic problem. Son of transfer and additional studying stabilizes, Liang Liqing's parents worked to private schools, to his son in personal school treatment and education during the school failed to achieve its responsibilities,Nike Air Max TN Kid, resulting in accident of puppy love his son and seriously affect their studies, resulting in his son was forced to transfer to by the necessitate schools to repay fares paid by the school, and repay the resulting losses. Schools that students love, is something the students themselves, the school tin only be guidance and education, but not physical coercion of students. Under the agreement, the school should be refunded Liang Liqing parents disburse the school fees, amends for the losses is impossible. As a outcome, the school refused Liang Liqing parent requests. After several circulars of fruitless negotiations, the June 19, 2008, Liang Liqing Liang Yiming father to son Liang Liqing is the accuser, as the legal representative of his own,asics for women, came to the Lake District, Wuxi City, Jiangsu Province People's Court, a chip of paper a civilian complaint, the personal schools Appeal court to require the return of private school prices 36,500 yuan, and compensation for loss of 3 million.
court, Liang Liqing Liang Yiming as the proxy claimed that his father: school signed an agreement with the private schools themselves, the son of Liang Liqing to the private school in fourth grade. In 2004 and 2005, his son in a private area that puppy love, and the same school girls passing note involving mature content, and occurrence of contacts with the girls , drinking, smoking and so on, which also seemed in a trance, anorexia, insomnia, worry and other conditions. himself and his wife many times to reflect the situation of private schools to require private schools to take measures to strengthen the education, but did not handle with private schools results. To this end, we were forced to all over the transfer procedure for. , mismanagement, should bear the corresponding responsibilities, return of school fees and compensation for economic losses.
in the proceedings, Liang Liqing requires private schools to give up 3 million claims for compensation due to non-infringement of legal rights, the court shall be permitted.
private argues: Liang Liqing in September 2000 to attend our school. I school in the September 2004 issue of Liang Liqing to be conscious of puppy love, to July 2005, our school has taken appropriate measures to promptly communicate with Liang Liqing parents were just as Liang Liqing good grades, so underestimation of severity. Therefore, our school has done to the educational responsibility, should not be liable for damages. School fees for Liang Liqing claim, Liang Liqing learning in our school 5 years, the annual school fee is 1 million, so the recess of my school is compliant to refund 3,500 yuan.
puppy love who is to reprove the students the results of two trials alter

Lake District People's Court held that, Liang Liqing signed with the private schools, direction, and not against the law, should be forcible. Under the agreement, to pay the school fees for Liang Liqing, the two sides agreed the middle of their own causes Ruoyin Liang Liqing suspension, transfer, restriction, more than two years, no refund; Ruoyin Liang Liqing private reasons that can not be natural learning and alive, leadership to students are not physically and mentally healthy development of private schools should be allowed to withdraw and transfer Liang Liqing and return Liang Liqing construction costs submitted by the school as part of the principal, provided by Wuxi Municipal Price Bureau, the annual fee deducted Party. Liang Liqing on August 29, 2005 for transfer procedures, transfer to contiguous school grounds, the reasons of its own half-way line transfer. Although Liang Liqing to private schools during the school girls had the same happen with puppy love, but there is no essential articulation with their transfer, Liang Liqing also did not provide other certify makes it impossible for private reasons for regular learning and alive,十几名安保被黑月饼“放倒” 工商部门介入调查, leading to lack of their physical and mental transfer needed for the healthy development, it returned to private school fees Liang Liqing requirements of not enough certify, not support it. Liang Liqing private schools more than two years after the half-way transfer for their own reasons, signed by both parties, permission.
2008 年 12 3 December, according to the law of the relevant provisions of the Court, first instance verdict, the verdict returned Liang Liqing private school costs 3500 yuan; discharged Liang Liqing's other claims.
the first trial, Liang Liqing opposition, the Wuxi Intermediate People's Court of Appeal. Liang Liqing's father, Liang Yiming said in the complaint: . but private schools, lack of management, not entirely concern, education, responsibility, son to private schools happened during the school girls puppy love with the same problems that can not normally learn in school and life, we are forced to knob the transfer formalities for his son Therefore, annulment ruling, judgment the return of private school costs 36,500 yuan. result, and later the school found that appropriate amounts have been taken; Liang Liqing transfer was due to the nearest school, according to pertinent regulations of the relevant procedures, not private schools causes Liang Liqing transfer. In this regard, private schools may discard the appeal and upheld the incipient decree.
court, after listening that the school should be based on the characteristics of minor physical and mental development of students, guiding them to social life, mental health counseling and youngster education. Education in schools for wrong behavior with a minor student, school and parents or other guardians should cooperate and be punishment. Case, Liang Liqing learning in school boarding school girls during the occurrence of puppy love with the same two sides note transmitted text contains morbid incompatible with both the content of the age, the issue of private schools after the finding of puppy love a longer period of time, not taken corresponding measures for students counseling, education, the private schools discipline fails to act relevant obligations and clash on physical and mental development of the Liang Liqing, Liang Liqing private schools should be allowed to transfer, and refund part of the school fees. Liang Liqing paid to the private school in fourth grade and third grade school to high school fees, but its only in the private school to junior high school second year, after subtracting the tangible student Liang Liqing school fees should be paid during the duration, with the leftover to be refunded by the private schools more fair and rational. According to the ratified private school charges fees, Liang Liqing in a private school from fourth grade to second grade junior high school, school fees should be paid 2.65 million, to pay school fees Liang Liqing substantial deposit of 53,500 yuan, and 500 absolute 54,000 yuan RMB, private schools should be returned to 27,500 yuan. Liang Liqing apply the court to order the return of private school costs 36,500 yuan, causativeable part of its hospital advocate, the excess shall not be supported.
2009 年 6 25, Wuxi City Intermediate People's Court made final, the verdict returned Liang Liqing private school costs 27,500 yuan.
judges say

early love of learning by students with parents of students sued the school cause requiring schools to bear the legal responsibility of the case, with the second example court's determination was finally settled. Second instance court's decision has aroused hot: puppy love affect student learning, school is not responsible for? School's legal liability for students puppy love?
this regard, the legal profession that love, as a right belonging to the range of private rights, is an utter right, others right to mediate, restrict, deprived. What kind of human, what kind of age, the right to enjoy love, if for love, the law does not apparently defined, it is impossible to make such a provision. Is love, while love is entirely decided by the acts themselves. For the love of the results, only to suffer by their own. Of way, the action of people in love, not always with the perpetrator's old, status, adapt, such as high school students, love is just a silly sense, their main mission is to learn to not puppy love. However, whether the criminal should be love, others can only be education, guidance, and can not be forced. Therefore, whether the action of others in love, and love the results do not bear any legal responsibility. Schools as the education sector, to students of education, management duties, in the students after the occurrence of puppy love, it should strengthen the education,白血病男子移植骨髓后体内艾滋病毒奇迹消失, guidance, exercising students the right to love here. However, this responsibility, but a social responsibility, not liability.
then, the tribunal in this case a fault? Answer is not. This namely because, in this case, the educate liable for the basis occasion of little dog love is no apt affect the academic rendition of students, merely namely the school violates the service compact, commitment is the rift of compact. Private school is a private school, catered that the paid educational services. Provision of schooling, method of its commerce; profit, is its purpose. Therefore, the rights enjoyed along private schools and obligations must be accustomed to its intention. Their rights and obligations of the parties at compact. Breach of contract obligations, we ought bear the responsibility. And Liang Yiming private educational services contract signed,christian louboutin pumps, will not affect the physical and cerebral health Liang Liqing duty as a school, because during the Liang Liqing puppy love in school, resulting in poor academic performance, physical and cerebral health naturally be affected, the school will not be entirely unloaded accord, we have to bear the corresponding lawful responsibility.
for students of education, compulsory education in China to the merger with the private education system paid. For compulsory education, due to a free, public welfare, puppy love for the students, without any liability. As for the private paid education, paid for and profit with the school puppy love to the students whether the legal liability is coincided by either service contract, not generalized. The occurrence of the case, but too to caution the private schools in determining the rights and obligations of either parties, you can not can not control the position on their own to inflate the scope of their obligations, otherwise, just can not bear the liability.