More than 10 years ago, public security organs have been found Xinhua News Agency reporters Li Li and Jing She
Xinhua Viewpoint: Henan same mistake again,, the
, accompanied by his family, Zhao Zuohai left Kaifeng City, the first prison. At this point, he has served a full 11 years.
the headless corpse who had confessed to the murder Zhao Zuohai Why
1998 年2 15, villagers report to public security organs Zhaozuo Liang, Zhao-chang called his uncle from October 1997 after leaving home, had been missing for more than 4 months, suspected of being killed by the village with Zhao Zuohai. Zhao Zuohai Zhecheng County Public Security Bureau of the Interpol team as a key suspect, detained more than 20 days after the release of the trial.
1999 年 5 8, the village when the village wells in scouring and found a headless body of a man without limbs, the villagers suspected to be missing Zhao-chang, a report was made to Zhecheng County public security organs. Zhao Zuohai again as a major police suspect, and has been detained in the Detention Center.
2002 11 11, Shangqiu City Procuratorate prosecution, accused of: 1997 October 30 night, the defendant Zhao Zuohai Du Moumou fornication with women in the village when there was also Du Moumou Zhao Sang affair of the village the villagers found that the defendant Zhao Sang chopped a knife, the accused fled the home, armed with a knife hiding in their own door, so Zhao Sang catch, the defendant stabbed the victim with a knife, causing Zhao Sang died on the spot Zhao Sang and then dismembered the body, hidden.
2002 年 12 months, Shangqiu City Intermediate People's Court on charges of intentional murder Zhao Zuohai death sentence, suspended for two years deprivation of political rights for life. February 13, 2003, Henan Province Higher People's Court after review of a ruling, Shangqiu City Intermediate People's Court approved the above-mentioned decision.
ruling, Zhao Zuohai not appeal. Custody, he was reduced by two, the first sentence was commuted to life imprisonment, later commuted to a prison term of 20 years.
Municipal Public Security Bureau deputy director Paul Chiu Chung said that the current public security organs have confirmed the identity of Zhao Sang doubt. May 8, 2010 morning, the old Wang Jixiang Zhecheng County family planning services, the reporter saw the
He said he and Zhao Zuohai is in the courtyard of the neighbors, good relations, they have one to work for three years in Yan'an, Shaanxi. Later, as 1,000 yuan Zhao Zuohai misappropriation of his wages, and their relationship deteriorated, with both having an affair with and Du Moumou and grudges. October 30, 1997 night, Zhao Zhao Zuohai Sang found home in Du Moumou overnight, brought home a kitchen knife, while Zhao Zuohai sleeping, Zhao Zuohai head of a knife cut, and then threw the weapon after a roadside temple in the Village, 400 yuan and identity hides the body, riding a tricycle, with a quilt, fled the home.
years, Zhao Sang visited Anhui, Shaanxi, Hunan and other places, but most of the time in home around 100 km of district activities, which lives in only six in the Taikang to seven years. 13 years,
louis vuitton handbags, he scavenging for a living. Over the years,
Louis Vuitton travel, he has not returned home nor for the second generation ID card.
his generation ID card was used twice. Once in 1999, he lived in Dancheng hotel when he was checked Dancheng South Fengzhen police station. The second time was in 2003, But the public security organs have failed to find that he was a
5 4, the meeting in accordance with prison regulations, Zhao Zuohai uncle, my sister came to the first prison in Henan Province, Zhao Sang told him that After the hearing, Zhao Zuohai first silent for some time, and then burst into tears.
truth, the Municipal Public Security Bureau deputy director Paul Chiu Chung said: the opposite, Zhao skirts should go to prison my son.
5 月 9 morning 8 am, Zhao Zuohai under the leadership of the prison guards, entered the provincial court trial set up in the prison scene. When the presiding judge announced that according to Zhao Zuohai acquitted after the procedure, in the face late in the fair, Zhao Zuohai could not help but burst into tears.
three departments are same mistake again
Shangqiu City, according to police, the reason has to kill Zhao Zhao Zuohai Sang as the focus of the suspect, because they believed that the work at the grassroots level Experience: general causal relationship between crime in rural areas is very simple. Specific to this case, a cousin of Zhao Sang Zhao Zuohai brother was killed, two families have any grudges; both women and Du Moumou village with a good friend, is the rival; Zhao Sang missing the same day, someone had seen two men had The woman in the house fighting; nameless corpse wrapped in woven film, his wife and son by Zhao Zuohai identified, was Zhao Zuohai home.
but some of the local public security organ, also told reporters that, in this case , some doubts do not pay sufficient attention to:
First, the police confirmed that no head, no limbs Zhao Zuohai body is killed, it did not trace the weapon, the weapon can not determine whether the scars caused by wounds consistent with carcasses. These do not meet our legal requirements for qualitative homicide.
second time the body has a high degree of corruption, police have determined to do all four DNA identity of the deceased. Therefore, the police identified the body Zhao Sang, a subjective color.
third time the police Canshi, identified the dead were tall, 1.70 meters. But in fact, missing Zhao Sang about 1.65 meters tall. These are not included in the police account.
Since then, the police transferred the case to Shangqiu two prosecutors after they have been because of
Zhao Zuohai custody 3 years and 3 months later,
coach outlet store, the case was political and legal organs at higher levels as a key clean-up of extended detention cases, called for the speedy closure, or release, or sentenced.
reporters learned in the investigation, due to insufficient evidence, Shangqiu City Procuratorate back in two volumes, rejected again, then volume. Zhao Zuohai the police insist that the murderers, not release, resulting in long-term detention in the detention center Zhao Zuohai. In the clean-up in cases of extended detention, Shangqiu Municipal Committee convened a meeting on the case many times, discussing the case. Procuratorate made: volume shifted to the prosecution the public security, to provide DNA identification. However, DNA identification is not the result, prosecutors finally gave up this doubt, to the indictment .
this point, Guang-Jun Wang Shangqiu's Procuratorate, said: indictment on November 11 to December 5 year sentence, the court heard the case after only 20 days. All the court adopted the views of the letter of the prosecutors, while the prosecutor's opinion is actually the public security departments.
in court hearings, the Zhao Zuohai and his defense lawyers have denied the murder incident. But the court held that Zhao Zuohai have done in the public security aspects of the record 9 times to kill, so the court denied the killings did not credible. In this way,
how to reduce SHE farmer named for April 1, 2005, was acquitted of the SHE out of prison.
now,
Higher People's Court in Henan Province, Zhao Sang High Court that this was an obvious wrong. The morning of May 9, Henan Province Higher People's Court held a news conference, declared Zhao Zuohai guilty. Immediately sent the prison, the release of Zhao Zuohai. For this miscarriage of accountability mechanisms and national compensation program for Zhao Zuohai has been started.
present, Shangqiu City has met the public , prosecutors, law-related personnel to participate in a joint meeting, in accordance with the requirements of established cases of Shangqiu Zhao Zuohai disposal working group, error correction according to law, criminal investigation Ripper case and other timely research; Shangqiu City Intermediate People's Court and to seize the initiative to correct the compensation according to law; Shangqiu City Procuratorate to organize a special force assessment of the case investigation, focusing on assessment of the original investigators check whether the law and discipline violations, official misconduct, according to survey results, serious prosecute those responsible.
According to report, when he was in charge of Criminal Investigation Zhecheng County Public Security Bureau deputy director Zhu Peijun, the current Municipal Public Security Bureau Director-line earnings. Ding Zhongqiu case officer, the incumbent Zhecheng County Public Security Bureau deputy party secretary, deputy director; case officer Luo Ming Chu, and now the work of Municipal Public Security Bureau Commission for Discipline Inspection.
Shangqiu City Procuratorate then appear in support of prosecution of the two prosecutors Wang Jihua and Zhang Lei, has been in a few years ago has left the Procuratorate, currently serves as counsel; Shangqiu Municipal Court presiding judge then appointed Zhang Yun easy-going case Judge Juan voters are still present a Shangqiu City Court Criminal Court work.
Higher People's Court in Henan Province, said Zhang Yong: There are many questionable points in this case, there was such a ruling, the three agencies are the responsibility of handling cases, and there is no basis of facts to the law principle as the criterion, did not insist on the principles of the Conflict. To the lesson seriously, a warning, the law must be responsible, accountable to the people responsible for the lives of the people.