This place is to the right of Cole's and has a big black door - I've walked by several times not realizing that it's another bar until I finally went the other night.
The bartenders are good and similar to The Varnish - you can tell them what liquor you like and they'll make you a drink of their choice from there.
The drinks are also reasonably priced - it was only $10 a drink
Newport Cigarettes, which considering the amount of time and great taste - I thought it was a steal.
But I don't think this is a must try spot for drinks - I could really take it or leave it.