Women received the money after 20 Yu Wanli boyfrie

□ Morning News reporters Luo Jianhua and Tong Xunyuan Hangen Nan

sons with disabilities in order to find a mate, who lives in West Road, Jiang Zhijiang can be regarded as well-meaning aunt. She wanted a new car, a generous loan, to seize the prospective daughter's heart, but the results a bit miserable.
At that time, Jiang aunt or through referrals, only identified by his son Ken and Li disabled girl friends talk about. However, at that time agreed with Li Li Xiaomei exchanges are not without cost. In advance, she said, by introducing a good aunt and ginger, may allow the man to her home, buy a new car Caixing.
Then, Li Xiaomei and Li began to talk about the friends, a few months, the two get along fairly harmonious. As a result, Jiang aunt to bring his son, the prospective daughter married as soon as possible, in July 2008 to honor their commitments. Industrial and Commercial Bank from her account, out of 20 million in cash, to the vigorous young girl to let her go buy a car. Li Xiaomei take their money while the afternoon, put the money into her bank to open in Shanghai's account. A few weeks later,coach outlet store online, she were to use this part of the money, photograph the license plate line, and purchased a brand new Fox car. But only in January this year, Li Xiaomei and Li break up a formal decision. At this point, ginger aunt for his son
daughter denied that they had received standard Apart from heartbreaking Jiang aunt, only through legal means to recover their economic losses.
the trial court in Zhabei, ginger aunt suggested that quasi-money to be too hard a daughter in law. Except in accordance with prior agreement, his younger sister 200,000 yuan to Li for a car,cheap louis vuitton, the other party to birthday party on the grounds is also obtained from the Li 1 million gift, plus their own after she had borrowed 20,louis vuitton shoes,000 yuan, For a girl who get married yet, it is too much. Today, more presumptuous because of her failure to meet requirements, the son of Li Xiaomei made and broke up. Jiang aunt that she has to Li Xiaomei before the amount of 230,000 yuan, speaking from the truth, belongs to the mother to bring his son, Li Xiaomei of the other benefits of marriage and bride price,coach outlet store, since the two sides failed to conclude the marriage, which should be a full return of the Li Xiaomei money.
Li sister's attitude is, and the break up is normal for your son to pay back the money, no way.
denied her aunt had received 20 million Jiang car models, also explained that the money was his mother's. As for withdrawals submitted proof of ginger aunt, she believes that it is deliberately Jiang aunt to her mother the money to buy a car the morning, from the bank for a withdrawal operation, the purpose is to trap yourself. She also denied that he had received from the Department any money Aunt Ginger.
in front of the judge's face, Li and Li Xiaomei tell her the real reason for breaking up: Jiang aunt had promised to use her money for the relocation of the old house they buy a new house, make arrangements for marriage, and he agreed In this year's relationship.
there is evidence of the gift, as appropriate return

ginger aunt to find out, the money exchange between Li Xiaomei, the court verified the following set of key evidence:

1 , ginger aunt in at 13:54 on July 5, 2008, 20 million bank withdrawals certificate;

2, 16:07 the same day, Li Xiaomei into their accounts will be 200,000 yuan certificate ;

3, introducer commitment on the testimony of a car.
With this chain of evidence, the judge found, Jiang Li Xiaomei aunt did have to pay more than 20 million yuan for a car. However, Aunt Ginger 3 million on other details, because there is no evidence that the court can not be accepted.
judges have judged that the Li Xiaomei Jiang aunt to 20 million, can not be considered in the traditional sense of the bride, but her sister and son in order to maintain a relationship of Li and the implementation of the gift. Although the gift delivery behavior in money has been set up, but now the two sides failed marriage, so the return of huge benefit, if not inevitably lead to imbalance between the interests of both parties. So the judge to consider, in this case, the larger the amount of the gift is appropriate, should be returned.
Zhabei court's final ruling, Li Xiaomei Jiang aunt should return the 150,000 yuan.